7(1)(c)
FOIAPersonal privacy
Personal privacy (records whose release would be a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy)
Read the full statute text on /statutes →
19 upheld (no violation found) · 72 rejected (violation found) · 17 partial violation · 8 closed / insufficient info / other, out of 116 documents.
Not legal advice, and not a per-exemption ruling — this reflects each document's overall disposition. See the FAQ disclaimer.
How the Public Access Counselor has treated 7(1)(c)
Section 7(1)(c) exempts personal information whose disclosure would be a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy. The decisions treat it as a narrow exemption that requires balancing the individual's privacy interest against the public interest in disclosure, with the public body bearing the burden to justify withholding.
In these decisions the Public Access Counselor generally rejected broad privacy claims and found violations. Termination and separation letters, disciplinary and misconduct records, officer names, candidate applications, and police and jail incident reports were ordered disclosed where the public interest outweighed privacy. Redactions were allowed only for highly sensitive details. Denial was upheld only where records concerned an alleged sexual offense against a minor.
At a glance: 116 documents from 2012 to 2026(42 binding opinions, 74 determination letters). Most often cited alongside: 7(1)(b) (Private information) (61); 7(1)(f) (Preliminary drafts, notes, and deliberative materials) (20); 7(1)(a) (Federal/State-law confidentiality — or public defender case files, for documents issued under the other amendment version) (19); 7(1)(d)(iv) (Would disclose a confidential source or informant) (11); 7(1)(d) (Law-enforcement/administrative-proceeding records) (9).
Recurring issues
- Public bodies withheld termination or separation letters of public employees as a privacy invasion. (A termination letter for a public employee, A police officer's separation records, A mayor's termination letter to a village clerk)
- Police and jail incident reports were withheld in full to protect victim or detainee privacy. (Incident reports on restraint chair use at a county jail, Police reports on a missing person's death, Police reports of a teacher's arrest for crimes against a student)
- Names and identifying details were redacted from employee misconduct, disciplinary, and attendance records. (Disciplinary records of a city employee, Names of employees in misconduct allegations, Police employee attendance records)
- Applications, emails, and internal letters related to public employment or public business were claimed to be personal or private. (An outgoing police chief's email to staff on policies, Applications for a village board vacancy, A letter requesting a vote of no confidence)
Practical points
- A public body should not withhold an entire termination letter, disciplinary file, or incident report on privacy grounds without showing disclosure would be clearly unwarranted.
- A requester seeking records about public employees or police conduct can point to the public interest in oversight as weighing against privacy withholding.
- A public body considering redactions should limit them to highly sensitive personal details rather than names, employment actions, or addresses tied to public duties.
Summary drafted from the linked decisions and checked against them; read the decisions themselves before relying on it. Not legal advice.
All 116 documents citing 7(1)(c)
- A termination letter for a public employeeBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A former official's correspondence with a contractor forwarded to an attorneyBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Incident reports on restraint chair use at a county jailBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A police officer's separation recordsBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- A mayor's termination letter to a village clerkBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Records identifying officers flagged under Brady/Giglio protocolsBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Settlement agreements for legal counsel paymentsBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Police reports on a missing person's deathBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Excel file of scattered-site unit addresses and occupancy statusBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A police department's case/incident report and related recordsBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A letter requesting a vote of no confidenceBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A police report of a DUI arrest and vehicle impoundmentDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation – improper redactions of driver statements and officer conduct; proper redactions of unique identifiers, dates of birth, height, and weight.
- Police reports of a teacher's arrest for crimes against a studentBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- An outgoing police chief's email to staff on policiesBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Disciplinary records of a city employeeBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Applications for a village board vacancyBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Police records of uncharged sexual offense allegations against minorsBinding opinionNo violation
No violation found
- Police employee attendance recordsBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Residential parking exception letters with namesBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Names of employees in misconduct allegationsBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Applications for cannabis cultivation center licensesBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Police arrest reportsBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Redacted narrative sections of police arrest reportsBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A school district's customer account information for water utilityBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Employee salary and wage records for 2016-2017Binding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Settlement agreement claims with a former principalBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Misconduct complaints against a former district police officerBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- A state police field report referenced in a crash reportBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Credit card and cell phone statements for elected officialsBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Contractor employee names in certified payroll recordsBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Crime scene and autopsy photographs of a death investigationBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Police officers' personal emails about a caseBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Staff bonus amounts after a fund re-allocationBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Information in a criminal complaint filed by a public figureBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A settlement agreement in a federal lawsuitBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Physician employment contracts with compensation detailsBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Surveillance video of a fatal rest-area accidentBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Settlement agreements under the personal privacy exemptionBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A public employee's résumé and job applicationBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- An investigative file on a real estate agentBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Index of PAC binding opinions on FOIA since 2010Binding opinionOther
Administrative index document
- Autopsy reports for high-profile suicide deathsBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Names of first-time freshmen and graduation statusesBinding opinionViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- In-car traffic stop video footage on DVDDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly assessed fees
- Audit data on railcar component originsDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation found
- Prescription drug order records held by a contractorDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Correspondence between a governor's office and a former agency directorDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Correspondence about state hiring sent to a revenue departmentDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A settlement agreement and remedial warning for a tenured teacherDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- University records claimed exempt under personal privacyDetermination letterNo violation
Improperly withheld records
- A school official's emails about morning announcementsDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Disciplinary records and citizen complaints for three police officersDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Attorneys' emails with factual updates to clientsDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A transit district's bus driver personnel fileDetermination letterPartial violation
Improperly withheld records
- An exhibit to a teacher's notice to remedy resolutionDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Student enrollment counts by feeder grammar schoolDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Police reports and 9-1-1 recordings in a retail theft and homicide caseDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Records on gating Griffith Cave and Natural Heritage Database accessDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Police records of a past burglary investigationDetermination letterPartial violation
Improperly redacted records
- An investigation of police officersDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- An internal investigation into a professor's research and IRB processDetermination letterPartial violation
Improperly withheld records
- Surveillance video of minors in a school gymnasiumDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Police use-of-force reports for 2017Determination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Campus safety incident reports and crime logsDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation found
- Police reports naming the requesterDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Death investigation records and police-federal communicationsDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Records on environmental and zoning violations at a freight siteDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation found
- A school district's settlement agreement with a student's familyDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation found; records ordered disclosed
- Police reports on a fatal motor vehicle accidentDetermination letterPartial violation
Closed, no further action
- Police reports and complaints about an individualDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation found; records ordered released
- Communications about scheduling make-up school daysDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- Police incident report for case 2019-48357Determination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Misconduct complaint records involving two city employeesDetermination letterPartial violation
Improperly withheld records
- Investigative records and photos of a 1992 murder caseDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation found
- Audio and video recordings of a police photo arrayDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Personnel records of police, fire, and water department employeesDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Security camera footage from a school eventDetermination letterPartial violation
Improperly withheld records
- Invoices and purchase orders for legal servicesDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Police reports redacted for attorney-client privilegeDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Disciplinary reports from a community collegeDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation found
- Complaints and investigatory findings about a public employeeDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A mayor's text messages with city officialsDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation found
- Emails between four individuals over three monthsDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Parking ticket data fields from 2015 to 2022Determination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Employee information covered by a collective bargaining agreementDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Police call records for a residenceDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Emails from non-city accounts used by the mayorDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- A mayor's text messages with public officialsDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Personnel files of three housing authority employeesDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A drainage district's maintenance assessment rolls and collector's booksDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Body-camera footage and 911 recordings of a YMCA incidentDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Redacted witness information in a police crash reportDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Police body-camera footage of a public encounterDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A summary of responses to an Invitation for ProposalsDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Application materials for a police chief finalistDetermination letterPartial violation
Improperly withheld records
- Police dashcam and body-camera footage of a traffic stopDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation found
- A city's email correspondence with union addressesDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- A police report withheld by a villageDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- Internal communications on a property development projectDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- I-Pass transponder and license plate data for an individualDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records
- A private citizen's contact details in a dog bite incident reportDetermination letterClosed no further action
No violation found
- Police reports on named private individualsDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Police body-camera footage of a private-residence incidentDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Police incident report of criminal damage to a vehicleDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Police records on Automated License Plate Reader data and investigationsDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Witness statements in a police reportDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Police reports and body camera footage of an incident involving a minorDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Police reports on child custody incidentsDetermination letterClosed no further action
No violation found
- Crash report with driver's personal identifiersDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Interview questions for teacher candidatesDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- A police incident report involving a public official and her spouseDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Unredacted police report of a medical assist incidentDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Job applications and résumés of unsuccessful applicantsDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Native digital files from Snap, IncDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Investigative materials and hearing transcripts from a 2013 disciplinary orderDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- 911 audio recordings of a suicidal person report and crashDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly withheld records