Meeting Conduct & Participation
65 Illinois PAC opinions and determination letters about meeting conduct & participation.
Meeting Conduct & Participation: what the decisions show
This topic covers conduct of open meetings and public participation. It includes opportunities to address public bodies during public comment, limits on interrupting speakers, requirements for established comment rules, physical and remote access to meetings, the right to record open sessions, and methods of voting.
In these decisions, the Public Access Counselor generally found violations where bodies cut off or blocked speakers, enforced unrecorded rules, held remote meetings without usable public access, muted open discussion, denied recording, met in nonpublic locations, or voted by secret ballot. It found no violation where a remote meeting was properly held or where interruptions were brief and did not prevent completion of comment, and it took no further action on a confrontation after a meeting ended.
At a glance: 65 documents from 2012 to 2026(15 binding opinions, 50 determination letters). Outcome: 35 found a violation (in whole or part), 12 found none.
Recurring issues
- Speakers were interrupted, cut off, muted, or threatened with removal during public comment. (A board's interruption of a citizen's public comment, Restriction of public comment at a school board meeting, Interruption of public comment at a board meeting)
- Bodies enforced public-comment limits not in established and recorded rules, such as time limits, address requirements, residency requirements, or advance requests. (A school board's unrecorded 15-minute limit on public comment, A home address requirement for public comment, Public comment access at a city council meeting)
- Remote meetings denied effective public access through missing links, muting of open discussion, or lack of a lawful basis for meeting fully remotely. (Remote city council meeting accessibility during a health emergency, A village board's remote meetings without public access, Muting a public discussion during a remote board meeting)
- Meeting locations and arrangements were not convenient and open, including private residences, inadequate seating, and barricades or security presence. (A school board meeting at a private residence, A village board's public meeting accessibility)
- Bodies restricted recording of open meetings, required advance notice to record, or voted by secret ballot. (Recording of an open school board meeting, Denial of permission to record a property tax hearing, Secret-ballot vote for a candidate recommendation)
Practical points
- Use only public-comment rules that are established and recorded, and apply them consistently to speakers.
- For remote meetings, provide usable access information in advance and keep open-session discussion audible to the public.
- Do not require advance permission to record an open meeting and do not vote by secret ballot.
Summary drafted from the linked decisions and checked against them; read the decisions themselves before relying on it. Not legal advice.
- A board's interruption of a citizen's public commentBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- A board's advance-request rule for public commentDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- A village board's fully remote meetingsDetermination letterViolation found
Improperly held remote meetings
- Restriction on public comment during a board meetingDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Interruption of public comment at a board meetingDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- A board's handling of post-meeting attendee behaviorDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A village board's public meeting accessibilityBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- A planning commission's closed-door discussion after a public hearingDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- A campaign town hall attended by a school board quorumDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Refusal to read a written public comment aloudDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Proof-of-residency requirement for a public meetingDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation found
- Swearing in public commenters at zoning meetingsDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Recording an open meeting of a village boardDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- Removal of an employee from a public board meetingDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Appointment of a new board member by a sub-quorumDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Selective enforcement of public comment time limitsDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Denial of entry to an open meetingDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A public body's interference with recording an open meetingDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- Restriction of public comment at a school board meetingBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Remote attendance by board members without adopted rulesDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- School board member attending a meeting remotely by phoneDetermination letterInsufficient info
Insufficient information to conclude compliance
- Inaudible audio at a city council meetingDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Board members' presence at a committee budget hearingDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A county board's removal of a public commenterDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Virtual meeting registration and public comment rulesDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A school board's conduct of public comment and meeting venueDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Remote city council meeting accessibility during a health emergencyBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- A village board's remote meetings without public accessBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- A housing authority's locked meeting room and delayed entryDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- A school board member's remote attendance and access to documentsDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A village board trustee's request to attend a closed session remotelyDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A school board's remote special meetingDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- Informal straw polls to set a board agendaDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A school board's failure to allow public commentBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- A school board's remote meeting via videoconferenceBinding opinionNo violation
No violation found
- Refusal to read a submitted public commentDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- Muting a public discussion during a remote board meetingBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- A city council's restriction of public comment timeDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation found
- City council conference call gatherings without public noticeDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- A county board's allowance of public recording of meetingsDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A school board's unrecorded 15-minute limit on public commentBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Public comment access at a city council meetingBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- A board's requirement for written topic and signature to speakDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- Remote attendance rules and public remote testimonyDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation found
- A member participating by telephone at a meetingDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- A community meeting attended by a council memberDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- Locked school doors during a public meetingDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- A county board's denial of public comment over a speaker formDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- Email correspondence between school board members about a referendum petitionDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- A county board's limit on public comment frequency per topicDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- Public comment restrictions at a city council meetingDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- Village board members' attendance at public forumsDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- A chamber of commerce breakfast with local officialsDetermination letterClosed no further action
No violation found
- A village trustee's right to address the boardDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed - no violation of OMA
- A committee meeting and action taken without a quorumDetermination letterClosed no further action
Closed, no further action
- A board's ad hoc limit on public comment time and questionsDetermination letterPartial violation
Partial violation found
- Recording of an open school board meetingBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- A village board's restrictive public comment policiesDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- Public comment restrictions at a council meetingDetermination letterViolation found
Violation found
- Restriction of recording location at a school board meetingDetermination letterInsufficient info
Insufficient information to conclude a violation
- A trustee's audio-conference participation in a meetingDetermination letterNo violation
No violation found
- A home address requirement for public commentBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Secret-ballot vote for a candidate recommendationBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- A school board meeting at a private residenceBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found
- Denial of permission to record a property tax hearingBinding opinionViolation found
Violation found